The best organic pigment set for artists depends on whether you want ready-to-use paint or pigments to mix yourself. I’d choose the Natural Earth Paint Artist Bundle as the best overall for artists who want mineral pigments plus walnut oil to make paint, while the Natural Earth Paint Pigment Sample Pack is a more flexible entry point for exploring dry pigments. For ready-made watercolor, Schmincke Horadam Naturals is the focused premium option, while Mijello offers a broader 26-color palette but is not presented as a natural-pigment set. The main tradeoff is between natural pigment materials, convenience, color range, and the work required to prepare paint. Read on for how these six options differ and which one fits your workflow.
Get the latest gadgets delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- The Natural Earth Paint Artist Bundle is the most complete natural-pigment route: it pairs 20 mineral pigments with refined walnut oil, but you need to mix the paint yourself.
- The Pigment Sample Pack lowers the commitment to experimentation: it offers 20 earth and mineral pigments without the walnut-oil bundle, making it a useful starting point for testing colors and binders.
- Schmincke Horadam Naturals favors convenience over range: five watercolor tubes arrive ready to use, but the palette is much narrower than Mijello’s 26 colors.
- Mijello and C.A.S. ALKYDPRO serve different needs from dry mineral pigments: Mijello is a broad ready-made watercolor set, while ALKYDPRO is a larger-volume, alkyd-oriented set; neither should be treated as interchangeable with the natural-pigment options.
- Green Stuff World is the compact earth-color choice: six liquid pigments suit focused applications, but offer less breadth than the 20-color Natural Earth Paint options.
| Mijello Mission Gold Class Watercolor Set, 26 Colors, 15 ml |  | Best Ready-to-Paint Color Range | Brand: Mijello | Paint type: Watercolor | Color count: 26 (24 paints plus 2 additional colors) | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| C.A.S. ALKYDPRO Artist-Grade Pigment Set, 10 Colors, 2 fl oz Each |  | Best for Multi-Medium Formulation | Brand: C.A.S. ALKYDPRO | Pigment count: 10 | Container size: 2 fl oz each | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Schmincke Horadam Naturals Mineral Watercolor Set, 5 × 15 ml Tubes |  | Best Natural-Pigment Watercolor | Brand: Schmincke | Paint type: Watercolor | Set size: 5 tubes | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Natural Earth Paint Artist Bundle with 20 Mineral Pigments and 8 oz Refined Walnut Oil |  | Best Complete Paint-Making Bundle | Brand: Natural Earth Paint | Pigments: 20 natural earth and mineral colors | Walnut oil: 8 oz, refined | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Natural Earth Paint Pigment Sample Pack, 20 Non-Toxic Earth and Mineral Pigments |  | Best for Exploring Mineral Pigments | Brand: Natural Earth Paint | Item form: Powder | Number of samples: 20 | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Green Stuff World Liquid Pigment Earth Color Set, 6 Bottles |  | Best for Model Weathering | Brand: Green Stuff World | Contents: 6 liquid pigments | Volume: 17 ml per bottle | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| organic pigment set for artist | Brand | Paint type | Model number |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mijello Mission Gold Class Wat | Mijello | Watercolor | MWC-1524P |
| C.A.S. ALKYDPRO Artist-Grade P | C.A.S. ALKYDPRO | — | — |
| Schmincke Horadam Naturals Min | Schmincke | Watercolor | — |
| Natural Earth Paint Artist Bun | Natural Earth Paint | — | — |
| Natural Earth Paint Pigment Sa | Natural Earth Paint | — | 256 |
| Green Stuff World Liquid Pigme | Green Stuff World | Watercolor | GSWC-10128 |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Mijello Mission Gold Class Watercolor Set, 26 Colors, 15 ml
For artists who want a broad watercolor palette without mixing dry pigment, the 26-color selection and 15 ml bottles make this the most immediately usable option here. It differs from the Schmincke Horadam Naturals set, which emphasizes five natural earth and mineral colors rather than range. That distinction matters: Mijello is better for varied subjects and color mixing, while Schmincke is a more focused choice for artists seeking natural-pigment character. The tradeoff is that this is a conventional bottled watercolor set, not a collection of loose organic or mineral pigments for making paint from scratch. Its listed four-hour dry time and lack of water resistance also make it a poor fit for work that needs to stay fixed when rewetted. I’d choose it for convenience and palette breadth, not pigment-making control.
Pros:- Provides 26 colors for a broad starting palette
- 15 ml bottles offer more paint per color than small sample portions
- Ready-to-use watercolor avoids the extra work of mixing powder with a binder
- Listed for indoor and outdoor use
Cons:- Not waterproof or water resistant after drying
- Listed dry time is four hours, which may not suit fast layering workflows
- Does not provide loose pigments for artists who want to formulate their own paints
Best for: Watercolor artists who want many ready-to-use colors for varied subjects and do not need to make paint from raw pigments
Not ideal for: Artists specifically seeking organic, earth, or mineral pigment powders, or finished work that must resist water after drying
- Brand:Mijello
- Paint type:Watercolor
- Color count:26 (24 paints plus 2 additional colors)
- Volume:15 ml
- Container:Bottle
- Dry time:4 hours
- Water resistance:Not water resistant
- Model number:MWC-1524P
Our verdict“Choose Mijello for a broad, ready-made watercolor palette; choose a mineral pigment set instead if making paint from raw materials is the point.”
C.A.S. ALKYDPRO Artist-Grade Pigment Set, 10 Colors, 2 fl oz Each
The C.A.S. ALKYDPRO set is the most versatile dry-pigment option in this group: its 10 colors are specified for oil, alkyd, acrylic, and watercolor, giving artists room to work across several paint systems without buying separate pigment ranges. Unlike the Natural Earth Paint Artist Bundle, which supplies walnut oil alongside its mineral pigments, this set focuses on named pigments and leaves binder selection to the artist. That favors makers who already know their medium and want a varied palette, including three bismuth-based colors and several distinct blues. The tradeoff is less emphasis on earth-only pigments, and the green and orange are preparations rather than single pigments. Prussian Blue is also recommended for indoor use away from prolonged direct sunlight. I’d pick it for formulation flexibility, not for a ready-mixed or exclusively natural-earth palette.
Pros:- Compatible with oil, alkyd, acrylic, and watercolor
- Ten colors span yellows, reds, greens, blues, and violet
- Contains 2 fl oz of dry pigment per jar
- Described as non-toxic and compliant with ASTM D-4236
Cons:- Requires the artist to supply and mix an appropriate binder
- Bismuth Green and Bismuth Orange are pigment preparations containing small amounts of other pigments
- Prussian Blue is recommended for indoor use and away from prolonged direct sunlight
Best for: Experienced paint makers who formulate colors for more than one medium and want named pigments in larger jars
Not ideal for: Beginners wanting ready-to-use paint, or artists seeking only natural earth and mineral colors with a supplied binder
- Brand:C.A.S. ALKYDPRO
- Pigment count:10
- Container size:2 fl oz each
- Form:Dry powder
- Compatible mediums:Oil, alkyd, acrylic, and watercolor
- Pigment examples:Bismuth Yellow PY184, Indian Yellow PY110, Pyrrol Red PR254, Phthalo Blue Green Shade PB15:3, Dioxazine Violet PV23
- Safety:Described as non-toxic; conforms to ASTM D-4236
- Container:Clear PET jars
- Model:P1544S10
Our verdict“Choose this set if you can handle dry pigments and want a flexible, multi-medium palette with clearly named colorants.”
Schmincke Horadam Naturals Mineral Watercolor Set, 5 × 15 ml Tubes
Among the ready-made paints here, Schmincke is the clearest match for artists who specifically want natural earth and mineral pigments without preparing paint themselves. Its five vegan watercolors use a gum arabic binder and can be used straight from the tube or diluted, so it is simpler to start painting with than the Natural Earth Paint sample pack or artist bundle. The focused palette—Celadonite, Yellow Ochre, Lalvarit Violet, Caucasian Earth, and Green Slate—leans toward subdued, mineral character rather than the broad color range of Mijello’s 26-color set. That narrower selection is a real limitation for artists who need bright, varied hues. These paints also remain water-soluble after drying, and listed lightfastness varies from three to five stars, so I would not choose them for water-resistant work or assume every color has identical permanence.
Pros:- Uses natural earth and mineral pigments in a vegan formula
- Gum arabic binder means the paints are ready to use with water
- Can be used straight from the tube or diluted
- Mixes with watercolor and gouache paints
Cons:- Only five colors, a much narrower palette than Mijello’s 26-color set
- Not water resistant and remains water-soluble after drying
- Lightfastness varies from three to five stars by color
Best for: Watercolor artists who want ready-made vegan paints based on natural earth and mineral pigments in a restrained palette
Not ideal for: Artists who need a wide range of bright colors, water-resistant layers, or loose pigments for custom binder experiments
- Brand:Schmincke
- Paint type:Watercolor
- Set size:5 tubes
- Tube volume:15 ml each
- Total volume:75 ml
- Colors:Celadonite, Yellow Ochre, Lalvarit Violet, Caucasian Earth, Green Slate
- Binder:Gum arabic
- Pigment type:Natural earth and mineral pigments
- Lightfastness:3–5 stars
Our verdict“Choose Schmincke for ready-to-paint mineral watercolors and a deliberate earth-toned palette, not maximum color variety or water resistance.”
Natural Earth Paint Artist Bundle with 20 Mineral Pigments and 8 oz Refined Walnut Oil
This bundle makes the most sense for artists who want to build an oil-paint practice around natural earth and mineral colors and need a binder included. It pairs 20 pigments with 8 oz of refined walnut oil, a practical advantage over the Natural Earth Paint sample pack, which supplies pigments but leaves binder sourcing to the buyer. The same powders can also be paired with other binders for watercolor, gouache, egg tempera, and ink, so the set can support more than oil painting. That flexibility comes with hands-on preparation: unlike Schmincke’s ready-made watercolor tubes, these pigments are not paint until mixed. The provided oil also makes this less of a universal solution if you want to work only in water-based media. Compostable pouches and recycled packaging suit buyers who value lower-waste materials, but the central appeal is the paint-making setup.
Pros:- Combines 20 natural earth and mineral pigments with 8 oz of refined walnut oil
- Pigments can be used with several binders for oil, watercolor, gouache, egg tempera, and ink
- Pigments are described as toxin-free and lightfast
- Uses compostable pouches and a recycled box
Cons:- Pigments must be mixed with a binder before they become paint
- The included walnut oil may be unnecessary for artists focused on water-based media
- Making paint requires more preparation than using Schmincke’s ready-made watercolor tubes
Best for: Artists ready to make their own oil paints who want a sizable mineral palette and walnut oil in the same bundle
Not ideal for: Painters seeking ready-to-use colors, or buyers who want only water-based paint and have no use for the included oil
- Brand:Natural Earth Paint
- Pigments:20 natural earth and mineral colors
- Walnut oil:8 oz, refined
- Uses:Oil paint, watercolor, gouache, egg tempera, and ink
- Packaging:Compostable pouches and recycled box
- Oil bottle:Resealable
Our verdict“Choose this bundle if you want to make mineral-based paints and value having walnut oil supplied alongside a broad pigment selection.”
Natural Earth Paint Pigment Sample Pack, 20 Non-Toxic Earth and Mineral Pigments
For artists who want to explore a range of earth and mineral colors before choosing a paint-making direction, this 20-pigment sample pack offers more variety than Schmincke’s five-color watercolor set, but it asks the buyer to do more work. The powders can be used to make watercolor, oil paint, gouache, ink, and other handmade paints; unlike the Natural Earth Paint Artist Bundle, this pack does not include walnut oil. That makes it a better fit for makers who already have binders or want to test different ones, and a weaker fit for someone expecting ready-to-use paint. The pigments are described as archival and lightfast and made without fillers or additives, with recycled and compostable packaging. Because the contents are dry powders, careful handling and a dust mask are needed. I’d choose this for experimentation, not convenience.
Pros:- Includes 20 earth and mineral pigment powders for a range of handmade paints and inks
- Described as archival and lightfast
- Made without fillers, heavy metals, additives, or petrochemicals
- Uses recycled packaging and compostable pouches
Cons:- Requires a separate binder to make paint
- Dry pigments need careful handling and a dust mask
- Does not include walnut oil, unlike the Natural Earth Paint Artist Bundle
Best for: Artists and paint-making learners who already have binders and want to explore many earth and mineral pigments
Not ideal for: Painters who need ready-to-use colors, want a binder included, or prefer not to handle dry pigment powder
- Brand:Natural Earth Paint
- Item form:Powder
- Number of samples:20
- Container type:Box
- Model number:256
- Country of manufacture:USA
- Intended uses:Paint making, epoxy, jewelry, and soap making
- Pigment type:Earth and mineral pigments
Our verdict“Choose this sample pack to explore a broad mineral palette with binders you already own; skip it if you need paint ready to apply.”
Green Stuff World Liquid Pigment Earth Color Set, 6 Bottles
I’d choose this set for applied weathering effects, not as a general-purpose organic pigment palette. Its six coordinated earth shades—ranging from Desert Earth and Ochre Earth to Dark Earth and Burnt Earth—make it easier to build dusty, soil-stained, or rusty finishes on models than to mix a broad range of fine-art colors. The water-based, fast-drying matte formula can go on with a brush or airbrush, giving model painters a practical alternative to loose pigment powders. Compared with the Natural Earth Paint Pigment Sample Pack, this set is ready to apply as liquid paint rather than offering dry pigments for artists to prepare themselves. The tradeoff is a narrower role: it is designed for weathering plastic and metal, not for replacing traditional powdered pigments or a watercolor set such as Schmincke Horadam Naturals.
Pros:- Six complementary earth shades cover dusty, soil, and rust effects.
- Fast-drying matte finish suits weathered model surfaces.
- Can be applied by brush or airbrush.
- Water-based and described as non-toxic and non-flammable.
Cons:- Purpose-built for model weathering rather than general fine-art pigment use.
- Six earth tones offer a narrower color range than a broad watercolor set.
- Liquid format does not provide the flexibility of loose pigments for mixing into artist-selected binders.
Best for: Model painters who want ready-to-apply, matte earth and rust weathering effects on plastic or metal surfaces.
Not ideal for: Fine-art painters seeking loose organic pigments for mixing into their own media, or artists who need a broad watercolor palette.
- Brand:Green Stuff World
- Contents:6 liquid pigments
- Volume:17 ml per bottle
- Colors:Desert Earth, Ochre Earth, Light Earth, Medium Earth, Dark Earth, Burnt Earth
- Paint type:Watercolor
- Application:Brush or airbrush
- Finish:Matte
- Surfaces:Plastic and metal
- Model number:GSWC-10128
Our verdict“Choose this set for convenient earth-tone weathering on models, but pick a loose-pigment set or artist watercolor palette for broader fine-art use.”
How We Picked
I compared these sets by how directly they meet the search for an organic or natural pigment set, while separating dry pigments from ready-made paints and liquid colorants. I looked at stated pigment count, medium or binder, format, likely workflow, and how much flexibility the buyer gets after opening the set. A larger color count only helped when it added useful choice without obscuring what kind of materials the set contains.
The ranking favors clear fit for natural-pigment exploration, practical versatility, and a reasonable balance between included materials and preparation work. That puts the Natural Earth Paint Artist Bundle first for its pigments-plus-binder approach, with the sample pack close behind for experimentation. Schmincke ranks well for buyers who prioritize ready-to-use natural mineral watercolor, while Mijello, ALKYDPRO, and Green Stuff World are more specialized alternatives whose formats or stated materials make them less direct matches for a natural-pigment brief.
| organic pigment set for artist | Brand |
|---|---|
| Mijello Mission Gold Class Wat | Mijello |
| C.A.S. ALKYDPRO Artist-Grade P | C.A.S. ALKYDPRO |
| Schmincke Horadam Naturals Min | Schmincke |
| Natural Earth Paint Artist Bun | Natural Earth Paint |
| Natural Earth Paint Pigment Sa | Natural Earth Paint |
| Green Stuff World Liquid Pigme | Green Stuff World |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Organic Pigment Set For Artists
Before choosing a set, decide whether you want pigments as raw materials or paint that is ready to apply. That single distinction affects the tools, cleanup, color control, and learning time you will need. These broader checks can help prevent a set from looking suitable on paper but mismatching your studio routine.
Check What “Organic” Means on the Label
The word organic can refer to carbon-based pigments, natural sourcing, or marketing language, and those meanings are not interchangeable. Mineral and earth pigments are typically inorganic materials even when they are natural and minimally processed. Read the pigment and ingredient details rather than assuming that “natural” means organic chemistry or that “non-toxic” means safe to inhale. If a specific certification or ingredient standard matters to you, look for explicit documentation from the maker. A set with transparent material descriptions is a better fit than one whose broad claims leave the pigment source unclear.
Choose Between Dry Pigment and Ready-Made Paint
Dry pigments offer more control over binder, consistency, and batch size, but they add preparation and cleanup. Ready-made tubes or liquid pigments reduce setup and suit artists who want to start painting without learning dispersion. A common mistake is to buy raw pigment for convenience and then discover that mixing requires extra tools and patience. On the other hand, ready-made paint may limit your choice of binder or how much you can adjust a recipe. Match the format to the process you actually want to repeat, not only to the number of colors listed.
Match the Binder to Your Intended Medium
Pigment alone is not paint; a binder holds particles together and affects handling, drying, and the surface you can use. Walnut oil points toward oil painting, while watercolor tubes are formulated for water-based work. Do not assume a pigment set will work equally well across watercolor, oil, acrylic, or craft applications without checking compatibility. If you plan to use a different binder, verify that the pigment is suitable for it and that you have the equipment to mix it. Buying a set that already includes a compatible binder can simplify the first batch, while a pigment-only set may suit artists who already have a preferred medium.
Prioritize Palette Usefulness Over Raw Color Count
A high color count is helpful only if the colors support the work you make. A compact set of earth tones may be more useful for landscape, natural forms, or underpainting than a larger general palette. Before buying, consider whether you need transparent washes, opaque coverage, muted colors, or a range of mixing options. Small sets can teach color relationships and reduce unused materials, while broad sets can save mixing time for artists who work across many subjects. Compare the actual pigment families and intended use, rather than treating every listed color as an equal addition.
Factor in Dust, Cleanup, and Studio Safety
Handling matters as much as color when working with loose pigments. Fine powders can become airborne during measuring and mixing, so follow the maker’s handling guidance, avoid creating dust, and use appropriate protective practices. Liquid and tube formats reduce direct contact with dry powder, though they still require sensible cleanup and safe storage. Keep pigments and paint materials away from food areas, label mixed containers, and check disposal guidance for the specific ingredients. Artists who share a studio or work in a small room may prefer pre-mixed formats even if they give up some control.
Pay More for a Workflow Benefit, Not Just a Bigger Set
A larger bundle makes sense when its extra materials will be used, but quantity alone does not improve a match. Paying for a ready-made paint set can be worthwhile if it removes mixing steps; paying for a pigment-and-binder bundle can be worthwhile if you want to formulate your own paint. For a first experiment, a sample assortment may reduce the risk of ending up with large amounts of colors you rarely use. Artists with an established studio setup may get more value from raw pigments because they can supply their own tools and binders. Decide which part of the workflow you want the set to simplify before comparing included quantities.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are all six sets genuinely organic pigment sets?
No. The lineup includes natural earth and mineral pigments, ready-made watercolor, an alkyd-oriented set, and liquid earth-color pigments, so the products do not all share the same material definition or format. Natural or mineral does not automatically mean organic in the chemical sense. Mijello’s broad watercolor set is best treated as a ready-made color alternative, not as a clearly specified natural-pigment set. Check each product’s ingredient and pigment information if organic sourcing or a particular material standard is a requirement.
Which option should I choose if I want to make my own paint?
The Natural Earth Paint Artist Bundle is the clearest fit here because it pairs 20 mineral pigments with refined walnut oil. It suits artists willing to learn how pigment and binder combine, rather than buyers who expect finished tubes. The Pigment Sample Pack is another route if you want to explore pigments before committing to a particular binder, but it does not include the same oil component. Before mixing, check the maker’s instructions and confirm that the binder matches your intended painting method.
Which set makes the most sense for a beginner?
For a beginner who wants to start painting without mixing, Schmincke Horadam Naturals is the more straightforward natural-mineral watercolor option because it comes as ready-to-use tubes. If the goal is to learn about pigments and make custom paint, the Natural Earth Paint Pigment Sample Pack offers a more exploratory starting point, though it involves extra steps. Mijello supplies more colors, but that breadth does not make it the most direct choice for someone specifically seeking natural pigments. Choose based on whether you want to practice painting or pigment preparation first.
Can I use the walnut oil bundle for watercolor?
The included refined walnut oil indicates an oil-painting workflow, not a watercolor one. Oil and watercolor use different binders and handling methods, so the bundle should not be treated as a ready-made watercolor kit. If you want water-based painting, the Schmincke tubes provide a more direct match among these options. If you want to adapt dry pigments to another medium, check compatibility and use a binder designed for that medium rather than substituting walnut oil.
Should I buy a large pigment assortment or a smaller ready-made set?
Choose the larger assortment if you want to compare colors, formulate mixes, or build a palette around your own recipes. Choose a smaller ready-made set if you value quick setup and want fewer decisions before painting. In this lineup, the 20-pigment Natural Earth Paint options support exploration, while Schmincke’s five tubes and Green Stuff World’s six bottles keep the palette more focused. A broad set can leave materials unused if its colors do not suit your subject, so start from the work you plan to make rather than the total count.
Conclusion
Best overall: I’d pick the Natural Earth Paint Artist Bundle for artists seeking a natural-pigment workflow with walnut oil included. Best value for exploration: the Pigment Sample Pack is the sensible choice when you want 20 earth and mineral pigments without buying the full binder bundle. Best premium ready-to-use option: Schmincke Horadam Naturals suits watercolor artists who prefer tubes over mixing. Best for beginners: choose Schmincke if you want to paint right away, or the sample pack if learning pigment preparation is part of the goal. Best for specific needs: Mijello fits buyers who prioritize a broad ready-made watercolor palette, ALKYDPRO is aimed at an alkyd-oriented workflow, and Green Stuff World suits focused earth-color applications. I’d start by choosing the medium and preparation level you want; that will narrow this lineup faster than color count alone.
Halloween Picks
Kalolary 12ft Halloween Witch Haunted House Inflatable Archway
Pumpkin Halloween Fog Machine with 12-Color LEDs, Bluetooth Speaker, and Remote
Haunted Hill Farm 4.6-Foot Spinning Beatrix Halloween Animatronic
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
